Close Menu
Nabka News
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • China
  • India
  • Pakistan
  • Political
  • Tech
  • Trend
  • USA
  • Sports

Subscribe to Updates

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news

Subscribe my Newsletter for New Posts & tips Let's stay updated!

What's Hot

France wants Palestinian two-state solution, says Macron

May 28, 2025

Trump says Harvard should cap foreign enrollment, provide student list | Donald Trump News

May 28, 2025

Can new US and Israeli-backed aid foundation in Gaza work? | TV News

May 28, 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Home
  • About NabkaNews
  • Advertise with NabkaNews
  • DMCA Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact us
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
Nabka News
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • China
  • India
  • Pakistan
  • Political
  • Tech
  • Trend
  • USA
  • Sports
Nabka News
Home » SC reviews landmark verdict amid absences, silence and restraint
Pakistan

SC reviews landmark verdict amid absences, silence and restraint

i2wtcBy i2wtcMay 27, 2025No Comments4 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email WhatsApp Copy Link
Follow Us
Google News Flipboard Threads
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link


ISLAMABAD:

The highest court in the land on Monday waded into uncharted waters as it began hearing review petitions against its July 12 judgement – a verdict that had handed Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) reserved seats in the national and provincial legislatures – but without six of the original judges, including the judgement’s author.

The hearing broke new ground in more ways than one, marking several firsts in judicial history.

The review petitions, filed by the ruling PML-N and PPP alongside the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP), are being heard by a 13-member larger bench.

Curiously, the majority of the new Supreme Court bench were not part of the original decision, and no explanation has been offered as to why the court’s constitutional committee did not recommend including the six judges from the earlier ruling.

For the first time since the 26th Constitutional Amendment was passed, the Supreme Court proceedings were broadcast live, a move hailed as a step toward transparency, though the absence of key judges cast a long shadow.

Despite the high stakes, not a single judge offered observations in favour of the majority judgement under review. Even Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar and Justice Hasan Azhar Rizvi – both signatories to the original ruling – remained unusually tight-lipped, adopting a tone of marked restraint.

In contrast, two judges who had not been part of the original bench raised a fundamental question: if the PTI was not a party in the initial case, how could it receive relief?

They wondered as to how reserved seats were given to PTI when they were not a party, neither before the ECP nor the Peshawar High Court (PHC).

Justice Aminuddin Khan observed that it was an admitted fact that all PTI-backed returned candidates had joined the Sunni Ittehad Council, which had not contested the general elections.

He pressed further, asking whether any PTI-backed returned candidate had approached any forum to declare himself as a PTI candidate.

‘Should the SC shut its eyes?’

The elephant in the courtroom, however, remained the role of the ECP during the controversial February 2024 polls, with most judges sidestepping the discussion on it. Though the majority judgment had held the ECP to account, only Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail pointed to the electoral body’s failings.

Justice Mandokhail – part of the minority who believed PTI was entitled to reserved seats – said that the presiding officers and returning officers failed to perform their duties in accordance with the law and constitution during the February 2024 general election.

He challenged the opposing counsel, Makhdoom Ali Khan, by asking: “Should the Supreme Court shut its eyes?”

Commenting on the matter, lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferii flagged what he saw as a glaring lapse in judicial due diligence.

“What I found most amazing was how some of the judges who were not part of the original proceedings had clearly not read the judgment under review. You are seated to determine an error floating on the face of the record.”

“You are extraordinarily doing so without the author judge and many other judges senior to you who were part of the original proceedings. Surely you can read the judgment for yourself and not rely on the arguments of counsel to refresh the most basic principles of the case for you,” he added.

Observers also noted that the government’s side appeared in a rush to tie up loose ends. Counsels for the PML-N, PPP and ECP all fell in line behind the arguments presented by Makhdoom Ali Khan, despite the original verdict’s criticism of the ECP’s conduct.

Insiders suggest that Justice Aminuddin Khan’s upcoming Hajj might be behind this urgency. There is speculation that the ruling coalition is keen to see the matter settled before his departure.

On the other side of the aisle, PTI and its allied Sunni Ittehad Council (SIC) have engaged four senior counsels to defend the majority ruling. SIC’s Faisal Siddiqi is slated to present his arguments today (Tuesday).

Legal circles believe that the current impasse stems from the ECP’s misreading of the Supreme Court’s January 13 verdict, which declared PTI’s intra-party polls illegal.

Besides, the court under former chief justice Qazi Faez Isa also came under fire for dragging its feet on PTI’s review petition – a delay that many say left the political field clouded in uncertainty.

Even the majority judgment had flagged constitutional tensions at the heart of the matter.

The majority verdict had quested how the matter of intra party elections – a matter of internal governance of a party – could trump the fundamental rights of citizens to vote and of political parties to effectively participate in and contest elections by obtaining a common symbol for their candidates, guaranteed under Articles 17(2) and 19 of the Constitution.



Source link

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email WhatsApp Copy Link
i2wtc
  • Website

Related Posts

Pakistan

France wants Palestinian two-state solution, says Macron

May 28, 2025
Pakistan

Netanyahu claims Hamas Gaza chief Mohammad Sinwar killed

May 28, 2025
Pakistan

Eight cattle markets approved for Pindi

May 28, 2025
Pakistan

Pakistan, Turkiye and Azerbaijan reaffirm unity at trilateral summit

May 28, 2025
Pakistan

Army chief Field Marshal Asim Munir holds talks with Azerbaijani counterpart on defence, security

May 28, 2025
Pakistan

PM, President mark nuclear anniversary with pledges of resilience and reform

May 28, 2025
Add A Comment
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Top Posts

France wants Palestinian two-state solution, says Macron

May 28, 2025

Swimming at the 2023 World Aquatics Championships Preview

January 5, 2020

21 Best Smart Kitchen Appliances 2024 – Smart Cooking Devices

January 6, 2020

World Music Day 2023: What Is It and Why Do We Celebrate It?

January 7, 2020
Don't Miss

Trump says Harvard should cap foreign enrollment, provide student list | Donald Trump News

By i2wtcMay 28, 20250

US president says Harvard must ‘show us their list’ of foreign students to make sure…

US Vice President Vance touts Trump’s crypto record at Bitcoin conference | Crypto News

May 28, 2025

Fight for the Pacific – Episode 2: Fallout Zone | Documentary

May 28, 2025

US to penalise foreign officials who ‘censor’ US companies, citizens | Donald Trump News

May 28, 2025

Subscribe to Updates

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news

Subscribe my Newsletter for New Posts & tips Let's stay updated!

About Us
About Us

Welcome to NabkaNews, your go-to source for the latest updates and insights on technology, business, and news from around the world, with a focus on the USA, Pakistan, and India.

At NabkaNews, we understand the importance of staying informed in today’s fast-paced world. Our mission is to provide you with accurate, relevant, and engaging content that keeps you up-to-date with the latest developments in technology, business trends, and news events.

Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest YouTube WhatsApp
Our Picks

France wants Palestinian two-state solution, says Macron

May 28, 2025

Trump says Harvard should cap foreign enrollment, provide student list | Donald Trump News

May 28, 2025

Can new US and Israeli-backed aid foundation in Gaza work? | TV News

May 28, 2025
Most Popular

Robot industry thrives in south China’s Guangdong-Xinhua

April 10, 2025

Xi says China, Cambodia set model for equality, mutual trust, win-win cooperation between countries of different sizes-Xinhua

April 17, 2025

Young PhD student preserves history of war against Japanese aggression -Xinhua

May 11, 2025
© 2025 nabkanews. Designed by nabkanews.
  • Home
  • About NabkaNews
  • Advertise with NabkaNews
  • DMCA Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact us

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.