Shogun’s Season 2 update continues a worrying trend with Limited Series

Recent updates about general Season 2 continues a worrying trend with limited TV series. The FX drama, based on the novel of the same name by James Clavell, was a critical success.Led by Hiroyuki Sanada general He cast the role of mastermind Toranaga Yoshii and was also in charge of producing the taiga drama. Recent news has revealed that FX is scheduled to continue general in the second and third seasons, Sanada will return as star and producer. This is a surprising announcement considering that the novel has no direct sequel, and has raised concerns about the project.

general Season 1 is undoubtedly great television, and its production team deserves a lot of credit.but general The ending was praised for its brilliant representation of Clavel’s narrative and thematic exploration. Making a continuation without author’s material is a very risky choice. It’s not a miniseries, but game of thrones This is a prime example of how a show’s quality drops when it makes a significant transition from a direct adaptation of a book to an original screenplay. It will be interesting to see how the season shapes up, especially without a character like Mariko.

Shogun’s Season 2 renewal continues the trend of limited series returning season after season.

Shows such as “Big Little Lies,” “White Lotus,” and “Beef” are also starting as limited series.

general This isn’t the first TV series to begin as a limited series and later be renewed. For more seasons. In 2017, Big Little Lies It was a huge success for HBO, based on the book by Liane Moriarty. Due to the popularity of the first season and strong awards, it was renewed for a second season. Despite adding Meryl Streep to the cast for Season 2, the results were poor, tarnishing what was supposed to be one of HBO’s best miniseries. A further success is that white lotus It was also intended to be a miniseries before being converted into an anthology.

Netflix beef is the latest show to continue this trend, turning from a miniseries to an anthology after its first season. Season 2 looks promising with an exciting cast, but the problem is that limited series need to be treated as a separate medium. When viewers start watching a limited series, their goal is to enjoy long-form but isolated stories that exist between movies and multiple seasons of television. If a limited series can suddenly become Season 1 of a big TV show after the fact, it will disappoint The viewer has it when they watch it.

What’s going on with “limited series” that don’t end in one season?

Streaming services want to replicate their success

Just like movie studios who want to extend the story by making sequels after a commercial hit. Streaming services want customers to come back to their sites for popular titles. For networks like FX and streaming services like Netflix, a second season of a TV series that has already proven successful is a safer and ultimately more worthwhile expense than considering a new project. is. With that in mind, the studio may not care that the original story or show already has a proper ending, but surprisingly, the show’s creators remain on board with the return. .

prior to General’s Ending, showrunner Justin Marks told THR As for expanding the series beyond the books, That said, “We love the way this book ends. That was one of the reasons we both wanted to do it, and it ended right there.” Just two months after the interview, Marks and co-creator Rachel Kondo are set to return. While there are directions the story could go, it’s strange to see the creators change their minds about this material, especially after such phenomenal success.

A show like Shogun doesn’t need a second season (regardless of whether it was good or not).

Shogun is based on a book and already fulfills its original story

While developing series such as white lotus or beef Anthologies have some meaning, general We never need another season.There are several reasons general Season 2 was a bad idea, and the main point is that it worked very well as a miniseries. The source material is exhausted and the character’s arc is completeand general Achieve thematic and artistic objectives in one season.

There’s a fine line to walk when discussing issues like this, as it’s not helpful to be overtly cynical about sequels or season two. While there are examples of shows that slumped season after season, there are also many examples where successes were not only repeated but added to. but, Artistic integrity is also important, especially when adapting the work of other authors.james clavell’s general Considered a masterpiece of historical fiction, general The TV series has a certain respect for its source material, but Season 2 risks undermining that.

source: THR

general

Shogun is an FX original miniseries set in 17th century Japan. The Shogun pursues John Blackthorn, who becomes a samurai but unwittingly becomes a pawn in Yoshii Toranaga’s plan to become a shogun. The series will star Cosmo Jarvis as John Blackthorne, Hiroyuki Sanada as Yoshii Toranaga, as well as Anna Sawai, Tadanobu Asano, and Yuki Keisoin.

cast

Cosmo Jarvis, Hiroyuki Sanada, Anna Sawai, Tadanobu Asano, Yuki Keisoin

season

1

streaming service

Hulu