Emerald Fennell's adaptation of Wuthering Heights is being described as similar to fan fiction, with some outlets using the term to criticize the film's approach. Reviews of the film are mixed, with some finding it messy or unfaithful to the classic novel, while others see it as occasionally irresistible or a needed departure. The adaptation has also been criticized for issues such as race erasure, but some viewers have found it to be a notable, if unconventional, take on the classic story.