Out of 15 Store-Bought Pie Crusts, Only Three Made the Cut

The New York Times·Nov 4

✦ NabkaNews BriefAuto-summarized from multiple outlets · verify with the source

A taste test of store-bought pie crusts found that only a few met certain standards. The number of pie crusts tested and the criteria used to evaluate them are unclear, as some reports mention testing pie crusts while others discuss chicken pot pies or puff pastry. The results of the taste test are also inconsistent, with different outlets highlighting different products and uses.

Full coverage

The Only Store-Bought Pie Crust to Buy, According to a Food Editor and Pro Baker

Simply Recipes·Oct 23

We Taste-Tested 7 Chicken Pot Pies—1 Tasted Just Like It Was Made From Scratch

Serious Eats·Feb 18

Even Ina Garten Swears by Store-Bought Pie Crusts—and 4 More Thanksgiving Shortcuts Chefs Love

Real Simple·Nov 19

I Tried 5 Store-Bought Puff Pastry Brands—Only 1 Gave Me Perfect Results

Allrecipes·Dec 6

I Tried Walmart's 2025 Thanksgiving Meal for $40: How I Made It Better

Business Insider·Nov 19

The Only Pie You Need to Make This Spring is Our 5-Star Rated Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Simply Recipes·Jul 1

I Tried Our 5 Most Popular Apple Pie Recipes—This Is the One I’ll Make Forever

Allrecipes·Dec 22

The Best Pie Plate of 2026 | Reviews by Wirecutter

The New York Times·Nov 26

View original report at The New York Times ↗

Fetching the latest headlines…