Mamdani has faced criticism for comments about a pro-Israel group and a response to antisemitic incidents, with some accusing him of inciting violence and antisemitism. There are reports of backlash against Mamdani, including demands for an apology from hundreds of rabbis and accusations from the Israeli government. The nature and implications of Mamdani's actions and statements are being debated, with some outlets reporting on a rollback of previous orders and a split among New York's Jewish community.